The other people on the boat couldn’t see him as we pulled into the dock. Their cameras were clicking capturing broad smiles splashed across lips blabbing in a myriad of languages. They had their backs turned to the statue, grinning alongside her somber face. Nobody but me saw the blue sailor’s uniform silhouetted against the grey sky as Second Class Gunner’s Mate Roger Calamaio climbed on top of the Statue of Liberty’s torch.
Nobody could see him because it has been over 60 years since my grandfather broke away from his tour group and hoisted himself up off the platform and into the flames of the famous torch that had welcomed his father’s boat from Italy.
Today the 354 step journey to the crown is as high as most can travel, and that is exactly where my devil-may-care grandfather found himself on his first liberty leave from the U.S. Coast Guard in 1942. The staircase to the old torch had been closed since 1916, but as my grandfather stood there he noticed a man working above him in the old stairwell up the statue’s arm.
“A workman was up there so I shouted ‘hello’ to him and he said, ‘come on up here sailor!’ So I went up,” my grandfather told me several years prior to his passing this December.
He chatted with the worker on the old observation deck of the base of the torch for a while before looking up at the torch flames and deciding to go all the way up. He carefully found handholds on the metal and glass torch, and climbed to the very top.
“From up there you could see…everything,” he said as his hand panned across the invisible New York skyline, his ancient eyes remembering the sights.
It was in his honor that I braved the sweltering heat and massive crowds of tourists to quest after my family history that lay on the two famous islands in the New York Harbor.
I felt a little bit like I was going through Ellis Island myself just getting through the intense security checkpoint to board the ferry to the Statue of Liberty. I hadn’t realized that since September 11th, the interior of the statue has been closed, only reopening to the public a few weeks ago on the 4th of July. Apparently my keychain pepper spray that I’ve carried for years posed a threat to National Security, so it was abandoned in a trash bag near the gate.
After the wobbly boat ride, I choose not to disembark on Liberty Island. I had a spectacular view from the top deck of the boat, and judging from the size of the line to get back aboard, I made the right decision. I sailed on to Ellis Island in search of my family name.
Although the architecture was beautiful, Ellis Island gave me the heebeegeebees. Black and white eyes seemed to peer out the pictures and speak of tired journeys, big dreams, and lost hopes. Behind the gentle din of the crowd I could hear the silent prayers of my family standing in inspection lines waiting to see if they would be allowed to pass through the guarded golden door. The youngest Calamaio child at the time was deaf, and would have been likely turned away, as many were, but his mother snuck him though the health inspection tests using hand signal cues instructing him to nod and respond at the appropriate times. She would tug on her skirt with either her right or left hand depending on if he was to nod “yes” or “no.” He was just young enough that it worked.
In the courtyard behind the building, I found their name. “The John Calamaio Family” was engraved in the Wall of Honor monument located between the building and the freedom of the New York shore. What there was no monument for was the thousands of unnamed rejects sent back to their countries of origin. The “homeless and tempest tossed” not welcomed by Lady Liberty’s lamp.
Since this country’s beginning, Americans have always tried to keep foreigners out of “their land.” Almost every nationality has been discriminated against at one point or another in our nation’s history, and though few people are denied jobs today for being Irish or Italian, racism still closes gates to people seeking the American dream today.
I’ve lived in Tucson the past four years, a hop skip and jump from the U.S.-Mexico border and the sector with the most illegal migration apprehensions in the United States. I’ve seen firsthand the hatred some Americans have for migrants. “Minutemen” cars line the deserts surrounding the city hoping to capture immigrants themselves. I’ve seen Mexican flags burned by men with guns in the streets of downtown Tucson. I’ve interviewed children wearing American flag bandannas who’ve told me they hate Mexicans.
Everybody seems to have an opinion about who should be let in and who should be kept out, but what many forget is their own history. I am only a 4th generation American, just as many of the Minutemen likely are. But yet there is a culture of hatred still alive and well in America, no matter how many people walk though the Ellis Island museum and comment on how horrible and racist of a system it was.
The Calamaios that made it though Ellis Island were the lucky ones. The immigrants allowed to pass through the “sunset gates”. The ones allowed live and work and have children who would someday climb to the top of the welcoming Liberty flames and shout to the world. They were the ones whose great-granddaughter would be free to travel across the country in a van and stand where they stood to say, “thank you”.